[Allie mentions having lost an earring in 311. Beth and Allie imagine David finding said earring. Carl can fill in the rest.]

Beth: "Carl, can you explain this earring?"
Allie: "...And why you're wearing my underwear?"

[Editor's note: Beth/Allie speaking above as David Scudder, not as Beth, or Allie. Get your mind out of the... whatever. -Rob]